is soy lecithin bad for breast cancer patients
The answer to whether or not soy is bad for the body must be qualied.Even the doctors who promoted soy have beneted from recommending soy to their patients.One benet is that it prevents the growth of estrogen-dependent breast cancer cells.Other names for unfermented soy include Lecithin, TVP (textured vegetable protein), soya, yuba, mono-diglyeride, soja, or TSF (textured soy Soy Lecithin What Are Its Benefits? And Is Soy Good Or Bad For You Anyway?The reason is unknown, but could possibly be due to the fact that breast cancer cells do not metabolize choline very well.October 30, 2014 at 2:45 am. over all can cancer patient with er positive pr negative take soy Many breast cancer patients were advised by their oncologist to avoid soy foods and products.My reading into the published research has led me to conclude that, quite the contrary, soy is beneficial for breast cancer patients. Soy is a food typically associated with a health-conscious diet, but medical researchers have wondered whether it actually could be bad for women whoThe worry that isoflavones could increase the risk of cancer recurrence among breast cancer patients was based on the fact that their cancer treatment This "new miracle food," soy, was supposed to lower cholesterol, take the heat out of hot flashes, protect against breast and prostate cancer, and offer a filling alternative to earth-loving vegetarians.Lecithin can be made from soy, eggs, sunflower or corn. The same year, soy supplements were found to have minimal effect on prostate-specific antigen levels of prostate patients. In 2004, consuming soy in green tea was thought to limit the progression of breast cancer.I use Soy Lecithin in powder form with my protein shake daily morning. You can find Soy Lecithin in almost all processes foods.But is it good or bad for you ? What is Soy Lecithin and What does it do?So when these phytoestrogens from soy are taken, especially on a frequent basis, the risk of cancer, particularly breast cancer, is greatly increased. Jump to a Forum: Welcome to Breastcancer.org - Info Resources for New Patients Members - Please No Posts!lmcclure4477 wrote: Just curious if soy is bad for breast cancer survivors. I am reading conflicting reports on it.
Are soy foods safe for breast cancer survivors, including women who were treated for estrogen receptor positive breast cancer? Answer: Summary: The current consensus among health experts who study soy is that breast cancer survivors can safely eat these foods. These predictions are based on experience with breast cancer patients with similar classification.Since breast cancer in males is usually detected at later stages, outcomes are typically worse.."Epidemiology of soy exposures and breast cancer risk". Breast cancer patients who eat the most soy foods are also less likely to die early, a new study finds.And, contrary to some fears, soy had no bad effects on women with breast cancer fueled by the hormone estrogen, the study found. Lecithin supplementation was also strongly associated with reduced breast cancer risk inHowever, blood from soybean sensitive patients showed no reaction to soy lecithin.
For several months I have been taking 1200 mg of sunflower lecithin daily with no known bad side effects. Related QuestionsMore Answers Below. Why is soy lecithin bad?However, the late Robert Atkins, MD, advised patients not to take large doses of supplemental lecithin without extra20 of breast cancers feed off of estrogen. Mine was that kind. I eat no soy and check bottles of creams for soy. (NaturalNews) Breast cancer patients who consume large amounts of soy may make the disease worse, according to a study conducted by researchers from GeorgetownMore news on soy. When it comes to soy, dont blame the bean blame the processing. Health Basics: What is soy lecithin? Transcription: Text: A Conversation About Soy and Breast Cancer patients with Wendy Y. Chen, MD, MPH, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, MA.Is Soy Bad for You? - Duration: 5:26. A new study published in the journal of the American Cancer Society, Cancer, encourages breast cancer patients to increase their chances of survival by eating soy foods. In the wake of of several controversial studies on this topic Some studies have linked the consumption of soy products with breast cancer. The findings have been mixed, but new research aims to settle the controversy. Soy is found to be safe and potentially even beneficial for women with a certain type of breast cancer. Soy has received mixed reviews regarding adult breast cancer prevention, but Marian says mothers may be interested to know about a large studyDont Miss This. Young Breast Cancer Patients May Preserve Fertility With New Drug. After Mastectomy: How to Choose Breast Forms That Work for You. The bottom line is that there are pros and cons to consuming soy lecithin, but its definitely not as bad as someMany allergists do not even advise their soybean-allergic patients to avoid soybean lecithin when it isIs soy lecithin safe in vitamin E supplements if I have a family history of breast cancer? Breast cancer patients who dont normally have soy should avoid it, if they have not had it previously until more research is conducted, according to DrI cant think of anything worse: Coleen Nolan rules out dating after split from husband Ray Fensome as she admits to enjoying the single life.
But its also good news for patients with hormone related cancer, she said. That the consumption of soy is safe and doesnt appear to impact survival is really encouraging, particularly for women taking hormone therapy for breast cancer, said McArthur. Breast cancer: Remember dont count the days but make the days count! Predictors for Breast Cancer Survival Rates. It has to be remembered that every single breast cancer patient has their own, unique scenario. Whenever the whole soy thing started happening where people were like its bad for you, you shouldnt eat it, I started to avoid it and I havent eaten soy, she said.New research now suggests soy is safe for breast cancer patients and may even be beneficial. It is primarily used as an emulsifier. But what exactly is soy lecithin?Women who are breast cancer survivors, currently under breast cancer treatment, or at high risk of breast cancer should minimize or even eliminate soy due to the potential risk of increasing estrogen levels. Soy lecithin 93 of soy is genetically modified. Soy lecithin can cause breast cancer, has negative effects on fertility and reproduction, may lead to behavioral and cerebral abnormalities. Could your daily soy lattes up your risk of breast cancer or lend a protective effect? So far, the research has been conflicting.The researchers looked at 140 patients who had been recently diagnosed with invasive breast cancer. For years, soy got a bad rap because of its isoflavones, says Marleen Meyers, MD, director of the Perlmutter Cancer Center Survivorship Program at NYU Langone Medical Center.Still, Id recommend that breast cancer patients avoid soy supplements, Millstine says. Is soy good to prevent breast cancer? The relation of soy with cancer presents much controversy and the fact is that it is still not known if soy is secure or not , as there are conflicting studies.- Soy lecithin. Soy and breast cancer. Because natural soy foods contain isoflavones, similar to estrogen, some people fear that soy may raise their risk for certain cancers.The current research does not support avoiding whole soy foods, even for cancer patients or survivors. Soy and Breast Cancer Risk. The American Cancer Society suggests that estrogen plays a role in breast cancer.So in conclusion, is soy bad for you if youre prone to breast cancer? Is Soy Bad for Women with Breast Cancer?Read the abstract of The Effects of Soy Supplementation on Gene Expression in Breast Cancer: A Randomized Placebo-Controlled Study. But its also good news for patients with hormone related cancer, she said. That the consumption of soy is safe and doesnt appear to impact survival is really encouraging, particularly for women taking hormone therapy for breast cancer, said McArthur. The Pros and Cons of Soy for Breast Cancer Patients Have Been Debated for Years. Now, research involving more than 6,200 breast cancer survivors finds that those who ate the most soy had a lower risk of death from all causes during the nearly 10-year follow-up period. Probably not: We generally do not instruct patients with soy allergy to avoid soy lecithin.Why is it bad to take soy lecithin if iam having a boy?Soy lecithin is not a harmful substance anyway and is not a risk factor for breast cancer or any other disease. GMO Soy Breast Cancer NutritionFacts org The hormonal effects of the Roundup pesticide on GMO soy put into perspective.There is a lot of confusion about soy lecithin because people take a knee-jerk reaction to anything with the word soy in it. Studies on soys effect on breast cancer have been confusing to say the least — some suggest that soy can lower risk of dying from the cancer, while others hint that it can interfere with powerful treatments. The benefits of soy lecithin for lowering cholesterol are well known as it has been used for decades in treating patients with high cholesterol. It controls the flow of nutrients in and out of your cells and prevents the build up of fats in the walls of your heart Soy Lecithin and Breast Cancer. Ask the Nutritionist. Q: I was diagnosed a year ago with DCIS, ER/PR.Our nutrition experts help patients follow a healthy diet during and after cancer treatment. Soy phytoestrogens may promote an increased risk of breast cancer in adult women by altering or decreasing natural estrogen, although the direct link to cancer is inconclusive.Bad Effects of Lecithin. So not only does soy prevent breast cancer, but women with breast cancer eating soy live longer. To see any graphs, charts, graphics, images, and quotes to which Dr. Greger may be referring, watch the above video. Soybean intake is increasing in the U.S. diet, but primarily through the consumption of soy protein isolate and soy lecithin in processed foods, soybean oil, and soy-based animal and fish feed. This web page is intended to examine the impact of consuming less highly processed soy foods on breast (Reuters Health) - - Eating more soy may be tied to better survival odds for many women with breast cancer and may not be harmful for patients treated with hormones, a new study suggests. Previous nutrition research has linked soy to a longer life Soy Lecithin Not Hormone Disrupting. For those avoiding soy due to hormonal issues such as low thyroid or breast cancer, the good news is that soy lecithin wont contribute to the problem.Healthy Soy Sauce: The Good, the Bad and the Very Ugly. It helps to reduce triglycerides and bad cholesterol while also being believed to elevate good cholesterol levels.Soy and soy lecithin have even been found to hamper testosterone levels ( soy is a phytoestrogen) and can even be linked to causing breast cancer. Is there a link between soy and breast cancer?Some of the most effective breast cancer treatments involve blocking estrogen stimulation.Is the inability of cancer patients to eat a concern?asked by: Steve Snodgrass Bowling Green, Kentucky. Soy protein lowers LDL, or bad, cholesterol by an average of 4. Soy isoflavones may helpAlthough its probably too soon for physicians to recommend soy foods to breast cancer patientsNote: Soy lecithin, a common food ingredient, is derived from soybeans, but is not known to affect55. Messina M, Abrams DI, Hardy M. Can clinicians now assure their breast cancer patients that Charge Estimates. Find a Doctor Make an Appointment Visitor Information Patient Login.Do soy foods promote breast cancer?Soy lecithin.Fatigue is a common side effect during chemotherapy and may get worse over time. Even so, it is not as bad as some people say. What is Soy Lecithin A Definition. This substance was first isolated in 19th century France.Phytoestrogens/isoflavones human estrogen imposters linked to infertility and breast cancer. Ensure and Boost drinks are often recommended to cancer patients, but these two have somevegetable oils (canola, high oleic sunflower, corn oils) and less than 0.5 of soy lecithinInformation, U.S. National Library of Medicine Is Soy Consumption Good or Bad for the Breast? Home Healthy Living Are soy products bad for cancer patients?Moreover, soy supplements can interfere with breast cancer treatment. Therefore, cancer patients should stay away from the consumption of soy products as far as possible.